Around this time every year, marketers are hit with an endless stream of holiday insights, shopping forecasts, Black Friday predictions, trend reports and lists of things brands supposedly need to do differently this holiday season. Everyone has their own set of recommendations, usually presented as though following them is the secret to unlocking holiday sales. We would like to add our perspective to that pile, although less as a definitive rulebook and more as a collection of observations shaped by several decades of planning and buying media through holiday seasons that have changed dramatically over time.
The biggest observation may also be the simplest: Black Friday and Cyber Monday are no longer isolated shopping events. For many brands, they have become the center of a much broader promotional season that requires considerably more planning than deciding what percentage discount to run over Thanksgiving weekend.
Holiday shopping used to have clearer boundaries. Retailers promoted gift buying as the calendar moved toward December, Black Friday became the major post-Thanksgiving shopping event, and Cyber Monday eventually emerged as its online counterpart. For a while, those moments felt distinct. Shoppers understood when the deals were coming, retailers understood when the crowds would arrive, and media could build toward a relatively concentrated period of demand.
The internet changed those boundaries quickly. E-commerce made it unnecessary to wait outside a store at four in the morning. Amazon and other major retailers began creating their own promotional events, extending sales windows and conditioning consumers to expect discounts throughout the year. Retailers started launching Black Friday offers earlier to get ahead of competitors, which encouraged competitors to go earlier themselves. Cyber Monday stretched into Cyber Week. Black Friday deals started appearing weeks before Black Friday. Some holiday promotions now arrive while Halloween decorations are still hanging.
By the time Thanksgiving actually arrives, many consumers have already spent weeks seeing messages telling them the biggest sale of the season is happening right now. That creates opportunity for advertisers, but it also creates a much more crowded environment in which everyone else has access to the same calendar.
The Holiday Shopping Window Keeps Getting Longer
A brand that once competed for attention during a few crowded days may now compete against holiday advertising throughout October, November and December. Promotional messaging fills paid social feeds, search results, retail media placements, inboxes, connected TV inventory and websites. Consumers encounter countdowns, early access offers, flash sales, VIP promotions, extended sales and last-chance reminders from dozens of brands at once.
The ocean has gotten bigger, and there are also a lot more fishing boats in the water. Consumers have plenty of bait to choose from, and they have every right to be selective about which one they take. Reaching them effectively requires more than showing up with a sale graphic on Black Friday morning.
Media planning has to account for the entire shopping cycle rather than treating Black Friday itself as the strategy. Awareness may need to begin well before the promotional window. Remarketing audiences need time to build. Search campaigns need enough runway to capture consumers researching products and comparing options. Social creative may need to evolve as the promotion gets closer. Budgets may need to increase during peak periods without exhausting the audience through excessive frequency. Post-holiday opportunities may continue into late December or January depending on the category.
Trying to compress all of that into a four-day media plan can leave a brand entering the most competitive portion of the year without having done much of the work that makes those four days effective.
Your Offer Still Has to Be Worth Something
Media can create visibility, but it cannot manufacture a compelling offer. One of the more important changes in holiday shopping is how familiar consumers have become with promotional tactics. People see discounts constantly. They have watched brands run 20% off sales in March, Memorial Day promotions in May, summer sales in July, Labor Day offers in September and early holiday promotions in October. When another 20% discount arrives on Black Friday labeled as the biggest event of the year, consumers have enough history with the brand to decide whether that claim actually means anything.
Some shoppers are also becoming increasingly skeptical about the value behind the products and promotions being placed in front of them. Online conversations around declining product quality, shrinking package sizes, rising prices and the general “enshittification” of products and services have become common. Whether every complaint is fair is beside the point. The sentiment exists, and it affects how people evaluate offers.
Black Friday itself has lost some of its mythology along the way. The image of people camping outside a store overnight for an unusually deep discount on a television or appliance still exists culturally, but many consumers no longer assume Black Friday automatically means an extraordinary bargain. They know some retailers are clearing inventory. They know a discount may resemble one they saw two months ago. They know prices can move before a promotion and that the percentage printed in giant type does not necessarily tell the whole story.
Brands with a genuinely strong offer have an advantage because consumers can recognize when something actually feels different. Exclusive bundles, meaningful price reductions, limited products, valuable gifts with purchase, free shipping or other compelling benefits can provide a reason to act now rather than sometime later. Media works considerably harder when there is something meaningful for it to amplify.
BFCM Planning Starts Before the Ads Do
A holiday media plan should begin with questions that extend well beyond channel selection. How important is the holiday period to the company’s annual revenue target? How aggressive are competitors likely to be? Has the brand spent the previous six months training customers to wait for the next discount? Are current customers buying differently than they were a year ago? What are people saying about the category in reviews, Reddit threads, TikTok comments and other social conversations? Are price, shipping, product quality or delivery timelines creating friction?
The answers to those questions should influence how the media plan takes shape. A brand heavily dependent on holiday revenue may need to build awareness earlier and defend more share of voice during the busiest weeks. A company with strong existing awareness may put more weight behind paid search, remarketing and conversion-focused social campaigns closer to purchase. A lesser-known brand may need a longer consideration window. Another advertiser may discover that its biggest issue has very little to do with media because customers like the product but abandon their carts after seeing shipping costs.
Channel planning follows the customer rather than the calendar. Search can capture active shopping intent. Paid social can introduce an offer earlier and repeatedly bring interested consumers back. Programmatic display and video can extend reach and support retargeting. Connected TV can create broader awareness around a major seasonal push. Retail media may matter heavily for products sold through large marketplaces. Emerging platforms can be worth testing when audience behavior supports them, although holiday season is also a risky time to throw money at a new channel simply because everyone is talking about it.
Budget allocation deserves the same attention. More competition generally means more expensive inventory and more advertisers chasing the same consumers. A brand cannot automatically expect the same budget that works during an ordinary week to produce the same reach, impression share or traffic during the most competitive shopping period of the year. Media weight, reach, frequency and share of voice all become more important when the surrounding advertising environment gets louder.
Consumers Are Shopping Before They Buy
The extended holiday season also makes the path to purchase harder to compress into a single attribution window. Someone may see a product on social media weeks before Black Friday, search the brand later, compare it against competitors, read reviews, visit the site again when the sale starts and finally purchase after receiving a remarketing ad. Another shopper may wait until the final shipping deadline. Someone else may intentionally skip Black Friday because they expect another promotion before Christmas.
Each customer can be responding to the same campaign at a different stage of consideration, which makes holiday measurement more complicated than simply assigning revenue to whichever channel happened to receive the final click. Judging every awareness tactic by immediate last-click revenue can undervalue the work happening earlier in the cycle, while giving too much credit to lower-funnel channels can make them appear responsible for demand they primarily captured rather than created.
Holiday reporting works best when brands understand how reach, traffic, engagement, branded search, remarketing activity and sales contribute to the larger picture. The exact measurement framework will vary by business, but the goal should be to understand how the pieces are working together instead of forcing every channel into the same performance standard.
Creative should evolve along the same timeline. An October message does not necessarily need the same urgency as a Thanksgiving weekend ad. Early creative can introduce products and establish reasons to care. Promotional messaging can become more explicit as the offer approaches. Peak BFCM creative can emphasize price, scarcity and deadlines. December messaging can shift toward shipping cutoffs, giftability or last-minute shopping. Repeating the same sale graphic for six weeks ignores the fact that consumers are moving through different stages of consideration during that time.
Standing Out Requires More Than Showing Up
Holiday advertising has become an arms race of attention. More brands are advertising, more platforms are carrying those ads, promotional windows are longer, and consumers have become extremely familiar with the mechanics behind them. Black Friday and Cyber Monday remain enormously important shopping periods for many businesses, but the dates themselves carry less automatic urgency than they once did.
Successful holiday media planning increasingly comes down to the combination of timing, audience, offer, creative, competitive awareness and disciplined media investment. Brands need to understand when people begin considering their purchase, what will actually motivate them to act, where competitors are applying pressure and how much visibility they realistically need to earn attention in a crowded marketplace.
A one-day sale can still work, and a one-week promotion can still work. The harder proposition is putting an ordinary offer into the market on Black Friday and assuming consumers will respond because the calendar tells them to. Shoppers have seen too many sales, too many countdowns and too many claims of the “biggest sale ever” to accept every promotion at face value.
The brands most likely to break through are the ones that give people a legitimate reason to care and build a media strategy capable of carrying that message through the full holiday shopping cycle. In a season overflowing with discounts and promotional noise, visibility matters, but a genuinely compelling offer is what gives that visibility a chance to turn into action.